Basheem Bennett, age 22 of Poughkeepsie, New York was sentenced today in Ulster County Court to 25 years to life in prison for the 2014 Easter Sunday murder of Ryan Gray. Bennett pled guilty to Murder in the Second Degree on November 10, 2014. His sentencing was adjourned due to a promise he had made to testify against an accomplice, Taquan Webb, a promise which he reneged on. His cooperation would have resulted in our office’s recommendation of the minimum sentence, 15 years to life in state prison, although County Court Judge Williams had only promised Bennett a sentence of 18 to life, and only if he cooperated with the prosecution against Webb.
At Bennett’s sentencing, Senior Assistant District Attorney Emmanuel Nneji recommended the maximum sentence citing that Bennett entered a crowded New Paltz college bar and fired a number of shots, hitting and killing Gray and also striking a young female.
It is seldom that my office enters into this type of agreement, to wit, to recommend a minimum sentence in return for a defendant’s cooperation. Bennett was given a rare opportunity, to acknowledge his crime and to show some semblance of humanity by helping to bring to justice another person responsible for this killing. Under all of the circumstances, the cowardly manner in which this heinous crime was committed, and then his reneging on his agreement, in our judgment warranted our recommendation of the maximum sentence.